omnist.world

Deutsch

Queer community · Compare this tradition with another

AI, Faith, and the Danger of Easy Answers

Queer Theology Podcast · Queer Theology Podcast · 2026-11-01 · Source

This text has not been analysed yet.

Show the full text
Welcome to the Queer Theology podcast. I'm Brian G. Murphy and I'm Father Shannon T. Elkerns. We're the co-founders of QueerTheology.com and your hosts. From Genesis to Revelation, the Bible declares good news to LGBTQ plus people and we want to show you how. Tune in each week on Sunday for conversations about Christianity, queerness and transness and how they can enrich one another. We're glad you're here. Before we dive into this episode, we just wanted to remind you that our new book, Reading the Bible Through Queer Eyes, good news for LGBTQ plus people from Genesis to Revelation, is available for pre-order now. You can buy anywhere books are sold. We're super excited to share these quintessential stories from our decades of work, queering the Bible and making this work accessible to people. So the book is available for pre-order now. It comes out in December and we hope you'll grab a copy. Hello, hello, hello. On today's episode of the Queer Theology, we are tackling the intersections of AI and faith and spirituality, both in the ways in which it's sneakily like the conservative evangelical fundamentalist theology that so many of us have come to heal from, but also the dangers of relying on AI in our faith life and the sort of parallels that we see in a temptation around outsourcing our theological engagement to others, whether that's computers or other sources. Shay suggested this topic as we were getting ready to record and I just, there's so many rich nuances here. So it might be a little bit of a rambly because we have lots of different directions to take it in. But to start us off, the Barnard group has a study that said half of all pastors use AI for brainstorming and idea generation and only 13% of pastors say that they don't use it at all. So it is already making its way into churches. Shannon also pointed out, I hadn't even noticed on Bible Gateway, if you go to welcome a passage, there'll be an AI generated summary of the chapter alongside of the text itself. And so it seems to be everywhere. We can't escape it. I'm trying my best to escape it, but like AI is being shoved into our lives, certainly by like websites and tech sources, but also it seems like pastors are turning to it as well. And so like Shay, what do you make of sort of like the dangers of over reliance on AI? And then also what are those sort of like the parallels that you see there when it comes to like faith engagement in general? Yeah, I mean, I think that right, like on the surface, it seems especially for many pastors as an easy tool, right? A really helpful tool. Pastors are overworked, especially of in many small churches, right? They're working two jobs, they're serving three to four congregations. And I can imagine that, you know, as they're thinking about sermons and even thinking about like worship planning, right? It seems really easy to be like, to go to AI and be like, plan out my next six months of sermon titles and passages, right? And using that as a jumping off point. And I think that... And then like you can see the charm list on the top because it's like, well, I'm stuck and I do all the work myself. I'm just like coming up with topics and passages. Yeah. And I see this even in the creative community too, right? Like people are saying, well, like I'm just using it for like idea generation. I'm not actually using it to like write the thing. But I think that for me, like part of when I'm approaching preaching, part of the hardest work of preparing a sermon is actually the generation of like, why this text, why now? And how does this speak to this very real congregation that I'm going to be stepping in front of? And like, that is the work that you can't source out to AI, right? AI doesn't know that congregation. AI doesn't know what they're dealing with on a Sunday morning. And so I think that like the first thing for me that comes up is like this idea that we're passing off the hardest work to AI when actually it's like the hardest work that is the most fruitful. And I think that is both like for pastors, but that's also when I think about spiritual life more broadly, like it's in the wrestling with the thing that the most fruitful theological insights, the most fruitful justice insights, right? That most fruitful things are the things that come out. And I was really just struck by the Bible gateway thing really struck me the other day where I was like, oh, this is like just like in evangelicalism where the pastor would tell you what the text meant, right? It was like, you've told the story of going to Sunday school and being handed a paper that had like fill in the blanks, right? It's like- It was like an adult. It wasn't like, it was like ostensibly for like note taking, but like not your own thoughts like right, recorded the correct answers that will be given to you over the course of this adult Sunday school lesson. Yeah. And I've heard pastors write the three point sermon where it's like, you are just writing down their points and it's not actually teaching you how to engage and wrestle with the text. And I think that like the AI affication of everything, but especially when it comes to scripture and theology, like is the same thing. And now you pop in a, I'll pop in a search, like someone will ask a question and I'll be like, oh, I actually don't know the answer to that of like when that historical thing happened or like where this is found in the Bible. And I get an AI generated summary and I have to really look at it and be like, is this correct? Or is this like, because what AI is doing, right? Is it's, it's skimming from the most popular websites. And so of course, if you really dial into that, the most popular websites are probably going to be conservative Christian. AI is not going to say, oh, hey, we got this from southernbaptist.com. It's saying like most people on the internet think these things are correct. And it's like, yeah, there's also a whole lot of people on the internet that think like the lizard people are real. And so is that where we want to be drawing our theological truth from? So that's like the first thing that comes up for me when I think about AI and spirituality and Bible study in particular. Yeah. And when you're talking about how like AI is then sort of like drawing apparently the most common thing, which a lot of that is conservative theology. And like, not necessarily because it's the most popular but because like conservative Christianity is this like machine that like churns out content and content and content. And so like, there's just a lot of it. It's we've talked about this also like you go into a book, you go to the Barnes and Noble, and you go to the Christianity section, like your problem, like pick a book off the wall and it's like probably going to be by conservative author because like most of the books there are by conservative authors. And so like it's not that like that's the most right position or the historic position or the traditional position or the most popular position. It's just sort of like the position that like has been gotten into bookstores and conservative theology has like really pushed hard to get that out there. And I think like for understandable reasons like progressive Christians are like wary of coming off too strong with evangelism. And so like we don't have fancy websites and like media companies just sort of like churning out articles and blog posts like like the conservatives do. And also like that but that also makes me think about how like AI presents what it's doing as like either like some new creation like even like generative AI, right? Like it's like here look at this like art that AI makes but like actually like generative AI is plagiarizing art or writing or music. It's just like sampling and sampling and remixing all the people's stuff and presenting it as if it's created something new or like you got all these AI overviews they're like presenting it as just sort of like here's the fact whether it's like an AI overview on Google or if you're like asking chat GPT or Gemini or Claude or whatever like it'll just tell you like here's your answer and it like presents it as fact and it doesn't it usually doesn't even like cite its sources it just sort of acts like this is the answer. In the same way that evangelical pastors teachers leaders even like people like you know regular folks in the Pughal just sort of like this is what the Bible says and they sort of like obscure that actually their sources are John Calvin or like Augustine or whoever like or Mark Driscoll or like a telephone chain of all of those people and then there's sort of like presenting it as like the plain reading of the Bible but actually it comes from you know this is like I love this thing all theology has a context like the so-called plain readings of the Bible are also coming from somewhere and in the same way that AI oftentimes like obfuscates that like so too does evangelical and conservative theology and sometimes like AI will like cite sources but they're just like don't say what it says it says and like similarly sometimes conservative Christians are like citing sources and it's like that's not what that says like what do you mean it's just like making stuff up it's making stuff up whole cloth. And I feel like part of what really concerns me right and this is kind of the crossover like I'm seeing even people in my life that I know who are turning over more and more of themselves to AI and who are like having conversations with their AI agents and who are like taking encouragement from their AI agents and it's I'm like it's it's not real right it's that's not it there's not a real person on the other end but I think that like this is this is what's pulling up Paul in Romans 1 and Romans 2 hopefully we've got you like nodding along at how terrible the evangelicals are and now we're gonna say like but also like they're there to go you right yeah and and I think that like right it it makes sense it is comforting to have someone else like tell us what to do it's comforting to have someone say hey AI agent like tell me the top three things that I need to get done today so that you don't have to like do that prioritization it's comforting to have to be able to like ask someone to be like what does this passage say what does this mean like how do I apply this in my life and it's it's such a fine thing right because I do think that there is wisdom in seeking out answers and sometimes in asking people of like I don't understand this can you help me understand it and also like the best I think the best teachers help you figure out how to get the answer for yourself and like that is bypassed by AI or a pastor saying no no no just just take my word for it like this is what it means this is what you should do this is how you should live it out and so I think that like we are in this moment where more and more people are not reading books anymore right more and more people are not even engaging with any long form content let alone like people aren't even going to sit through films anymore I shared that I shared that story with you about like film students at one of the top universities couldn't sit through an entire movie without checking their phone like our attention is not what it used to be yeah and and I don't want to be like old man yelling at clouds and also I think like we're in a concerning moment right because spiritual growth like the journey of spiritual growth is like windy and complicated and long and it's not a list of checkpoints I was sitting in a conference the other week and I just had this moment where I was like oh like so many the people around me are thinking about spiritual life and spiritual growth as like a checkpoint like it's a list right I said the prayer and now I like got baptized and now I join a church and now I like go to a small group and now I disciple someone else right and it's like you do all of these things and then it eventually it's just like boom you're you're spiritually grown and I thought like oh this is also it's also so appealing because it's really easy to put a number on it right we have x number of people who have prayed the prayer we've baptized x number of people we've got this many people in small groups we've got this many people discipling someone else and it's like faith isn't supposed to be like that right it's messy and it's complicated and it like you take three steps forward and then four steps back and then someone dies and you're stuck in grief for six months and then you actually come out on the other side of that grief with a profound understanding that is new and different but like that put you in a totally different place than you were before right like none of this is linear and I think that my fear is that the more we lean on things like AI and on gz answers like we we long for the checklist but like the checklist is not good for us yeah and listen I like my ADHD I love I love a checklist me too so I get it but it's like a it's I think it's like a yes and right like sometimes I have my checklist but sometimes like checklists is like do the hardship thing you don't want to do um like I like we're you know it's the modern era so many of us like live so well like most people in America have air conditioning which like 200 years ago like kings didn't have air conditioning right like like what what luxury and also like so like I don't I'm I can be prissy like I like to be comfortable right I don't like being too hot I don't like being too cold I don't like not being able to like lay down I don't like going to gay bars which we want without being able to sit away and also so like I get so like I understand the the longing for ease and also like friction is like is good for you that like right when I think about like learning to play an instrument right you like you I like I played the saxophone I like so many times a lot like I squeak learning to play the saxophone or fumble like fingerings or like I I've tried to play the guitar you get like calluses it hurts like learning I'm you know I've been like learning Danish like staring at a children's book and being like I understand only half of this kid's book right we're like wanting to go faster like learning to cook and baking like burning your burning your bread or having your souffle collapse or like whatever it is like the friction is part of the growth and like I don't know I you know you and I like both the month or periods are like trying to like meditate every day or like say daily prayers or you know when we were recording the Korean the Bible original sort of like video course like way back in the day we were like at a monastery and we would go like pray the daily office with the monks and it's like I don't know it's like uncomfortable to get up at 6 a.m to go like trudge down to the monastery to like pray these like old prayers that like people have been praying for thousands of years like and also like there's like some magic there I also think about like with friction right like like I'm trying to think about how the memes are phrased but like all of the gay like all the gay beaches especially like the gay like naked parts of the beaches it's like you have to like climb down a cliff or you have to like forge a marsh like you have to like we like queer people often like you have to the the queer clubs and like a Brooklyn you have to like take the L train into far off Brooklyn and like go down just like warehouse right like there's like something about like uh like the journey also is like what makes it and so like like when you think about like in our book I spent our last chapter sort of like the reconciliation of all things like I don't think that we're going to create the kingdom of God and earth as it is in heaven like that's not gonna that's like not an easy task right um you and I were just I was on jury duty we were just talking about like the prison system and like prison reform and the cultural state like that like that's that's messy there's a lot of friction there's not an AI answer that we're going to be able to like pop out and like oh like Klaus said here's the here's the six point plan let's let's all just like agree to this or being in relationship with your less than a farming family all of this like takes some friction and so like we can't just like outsource our thinking or like flinch at this this this like slightest bit of friction that actually like leaning into the friction and getting comfortable with the friction um is a like a really important skill I'd like to develop I think like for spiritual growth for like political activism growth for like interpersonal growth um that like yeah it's it's important I think like you know like Leveron Cox talks about possibility models and so like the one that I think you and I in this work like we tell our stories as like a model for like engaging in faith in a new way and also it's always paired with we want to help you see yourself in in the Bible we don't just want it to be us right like I remember like back in the Tumblr days like we were constantly getting messages from people that like is it okay to masturbate is like premarital sex okay like is it okay to watch porn and like I have like my answers but like if you join sanctuary collective's personal study hall and like you go through like sex positive spirituality like it is not taking notes and like what Brian and Shay say it's gonna be like here are some texts to wrestle with here are some questions to ask yourself like we have some like frameworks in some places to get you started but like ultimately you've got to figure that out for yourself and like not because we're being like annoying teachers but because like it will also be so much more real when it's the faith that you fought for and I think like if you're listening to the a podcast called queer theology 14 years after we started it like you care about faith too and so like you're not you're not here by accident and so like really like sort of like leaning into the making it your own is I think so valuable we hope you enjoyed this episode if you would like to go deeper into the ways that queerness can enrich faith and faith can enrich queerness then you have got to check out our new book reading the bible through queer eyes which comes out december at first it is a devil for pre-order now everywhere books are sold the queer theology podcast is just one of many things that we do at queertheology.com which provides resources community and inspiration for LGBTQ Christians and straight cisgender supporters to dive into more of the action visit us at queertheology.com you can also connect with us online on facebook twitter tumblr and instagram we'll see you next week