omnist.world

Deutsch

Zen · Compare this tradition with another

The Proliferation of Stories

Upaya Zen Center Santa Fe - Dharma Podcast · Upaya Zen Center Santa Fe - Dharma Podcast · 2026-11-02 · Santa Fe · Source

Knowledge · main message Humility · carrying Repentance · carrying

Das menschliche Leiden entsteht primär durch die unbewusste Projektion und Anhaftung an selbst konstruierte narrative Geschichten, die durch meditative Achtsamkeit als Illusionen entlarvt und gelöst werden können.

Die Proliferation ist die Vielheit der Gedanken und Wahrnehmungen, die der Geist hervorbringt und die das Herz belagern.

Der Text analysiert die menschliche Tendenz, zufällige Eindrücke als kohärente Geschichten zu interpretieren, basierend auf einem psychologischen Experiment aus den 1940er Jahren. Der Sprecher Clayton Dalton verknüpft diese kognitive Mechanik mit dem buddhistischen Konzept der 'Proliferation' (Proliferation of thoughts), die als Quelle von Leid und Anhaftung gilt. Er beschreibt, wie Meditation als 'Laboratorium' dient, um diese endlosen narrativen Schleifen im Geist zu beobachten und zu durchbrechen. Als konkretes Beispiel erzählt er von einem Vorfall in der Notaufnahme, in dem er zunächst wütend auf einen betrunkenen Patienten reagierte, bevor er später dessen Depression und Reue erlebte. Diese Erfahrung veranschaulicht, wie die Projektion eigener Geschichten auf andere Menschen zu Missverständnissen und Leid führt. Der Text betont, dass das Bewusstsein für diese narrativen Konstruktionen der Schlüssel ist, um aus der Verstrickung in eigene Illusionen zu befreien.

Worldview

what this means
What, according to this text, is the root of the evil?
Clinging, desire, the inability to let go; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality
Where does the evil reside?
in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual
What helps against it?
insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice
What is human being according to this text?
entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free
Where is history heading?
recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern
What does the text base its claim on?
on personal experience, testimony, encounter; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice
To whom does the text's call for devotion apply?
to every human being, regardless of faith
Where is the text's criticism directed?
at one's own community and at oneself

Related texts from other traditions

by similarity of the analysis, one text per tradition

What the text calls for

Measured

Basic stance
1 from -2 to 2
Insistence
2 of 3
Reach
1 of 5
Concreteness
3 of 3
Boundary
0 of 3
Time
past 1, present 3, future 1

Analysed with qwen/qwen3.8-27b, version v3. The same standards apply to every tradition, see Values.

Show the full text
Thank you for listening to UPIA's Dharma podcast, an extraordinary series of talks from some of the finest teachers in the world. I'm Joan Halifax, founder of the UPIA's End Center, and we're happy to make these podcasts available to you. Please consider making a donation so we can offer these recordings freely. You'll find a donation button on our podcast page. And thank you so much. This is DharmaPodcast at DharmaPodcast.org. This is episode number 2686. It was recorded on October 28, 2026. And it is titled, The Proliferation of Stories. The speaker for this episode is Clayton Dalton. Thank you everyone for coming. Can you hear me? Yes, no. Yes. No, louder. How about now? Good. Thank you everyone for coming. What a wonderful day. Beautiful weather outside. Before I start, thank you to Roshi, the guiding presence of this temple. And thank you to the residents. None of this would be possible without the residents who support this whole place of practice and community. So, deep bow to all of them. Thank you for your labor. I'm going to start with a short video. I can't see the screen. Oh, I kind of can. And John, we can just play it whenever you're ready. I think it's a minute and a half or something like that. Oh, yeah. It seems like this screen is not on. You could just turn this one a little bit maybe, so everyone can see. Now I can see too. We'll just do one more time and then we'll proceed. How many people saw characters? Or some sort of story? So this was an experiment. This was an experiment that was designed and conducted in the 1940s by two psychologists. And they showed that clip to 34 undergraduates, the workhorses of all psychological experiments. And then afterwards they asked them what they had seen. They said what happened when people write down what they saw. And almost everyone saw some kind of story. One person who, I don't know what their actual response was, but in the paper they reported that 33 of the 34 students saw some sort of drama playing out, some sort of narrative or story. And they related to characters that they imagined they were seeing in these shapes. But there was no story. This was just random shapes, symbols. There was no actual story that was being depicted. And so the experiment was designed to see how people would interpret things. And the conclusion that was drawn is that our impulse is to project the kind of meaning onto whatever it is that we see. And that it usually takes the shape of some kind of story, some sort of narrative. And these students didn't really even necessarily notice that that's what they were doing. They just saw it in a sort of seamless way. They saw some sort of bullying happen or some sort of love affair happening or some sort of drama. They just saw it. They didn't say, well, it kind of looks to me like maybe something like this has happened. And just that's just what they saw. And so this experiment was sort of integral to what is now a fairly extensive body of scientific literature that seems to suggest that we do this all the time. We see the world in terms of stories. We project meaning onto the world. We interpret things. We derive a sense of meaning. We project a sense of meaning. And so stories are the stuff of thinking and understanding has to do with the way that we understand ourselves and our place in the world and our groups and even enemies. But we don't really notice it. This is something that just sort of is the substance of thinking. And we don't often have a lot of awareness that it often takes these shapes. And so it can be useful to start to pay attention to the way that this happens inside of our own minds. Something else that I think is important to notice is that the reason why this can happen in such a seamless way is because it is really fast and it just so quickly grabs us in its current or momentum, just wraps us up quickly. So you don't even notice what's happening a lot of the time. It just moves so quickly. There's so much gravity to whatever story kind of arises and pulls us along with it that all of a sudden we're somewhere completely different somewhere else entirely. And this is so true for all of us that the psychologist who created the film in his autobiography that was published 40 years later and reflecting on this experiment actually admitted that he did have a story in mind. He conceived of the idea. Random shapes and symbols had no meaning. See if people project their own meaning onto it. But he himself couldn't resist the impulse. He had a particular story in mind of what he saw. So even though he was sort of primed to be aware of this dynamic, he couldn't resist it himself. I think that's pretty instructive. And so one of the things that can happen during meditation is that you can start to notice that this happens. You can start to notice that these stories kind of just proliferate endlessly from a seemingly inexhaustible well. And they can become quite elaborate and they can really suck you into some strange places to take you far away into the future, far away into the past. A memory might turn into a story or a missed opportunity or something that you need to do or a future wish or some sort of idea about work or anticipation. These all tend to arrive as a kind of story or a fragment of the story and then they can give rise to further stories. And we might also notice that during meditation that rumination often takes the form of a kind of narrative or a story. We often tell ourselves a story about ourselves and it's often surprisingly harsh or even cool. And you can start to see this because there's just nothing else to distract you when you're sitting absolutely still facing a wall. There's just not that much else going on. That's sort of by design. It's a kind of, the Zindo is a kind of laboratory for just observing things that are happening in your mind all the time. But when we have so many other distractions, it can be very easy not to notice them. So we might think I'm not good enough or I'm not smart enough or I'm not disciplined enough. We might think that we are a certain kind of person subject to a certain kind of life. And this is often a source of distress. This is what comes up for me a lot during Zazen, probably for many of you too. And sometimes we may come to realize that we are speaking to ourselves in a way that we would never speak to a friend or a stranger or really anyone else for that matter. And yet we talk to ourselves in that way. Sometimes it can be a startling recognition. The first time that you become aware that this is what you've been doing this whole time. Is it possible that this sort of story has really been playing on repeat, looping endless variations of itself for all of these years and just now noticed it? Yeah, very much. And once you've begun to glimpse this process during meditation, you might start to see it everywhere because indeed it is everywhere. We have certain stories about politics for instance, Republicans and Democrats. There are stories about people who are immigrants, or about the economy, or about tech oligarchs, or stories about Palestinians and Israelis, or about climate change, or about the future. These are all stories, are all stories that proliferate around all of these various things. And in Buddhism there is a word for this. The word is Papacha. And it's one of those polywords that don't totally translate into English. They sort of carry a family of associations with them. But this word is usually translated as proliferation. And it also carries a suggestion of an illusion or an obsession, and also obstacle or impediment. So a proliferation of illusion, which is an impediment. That sounds familiar to me for sure. This is pretty much the state of my mind, almost all the time. And another translation of this word that I like is, the multiplicity of thoughts and perceptions that the mind produces, and which beset the heart. The Pancha is the multiplicity of thoughts and perceptions that the mind produces, and which beset the heart. I think the last part is important, which beset the heart. I think that tells us something about why this is a problem. There's a Buddhist philosopher called Nagarjuna, and he calls this process a reification of our own fabrications. A reification of our own fabrications. That's his take on this term, this idea. And he says, Nagarjuna, that from our attachment to these fabrications arise the three poisons, greed, hatred, and delusion. I feel that my work in the hospital has illustrated the truth of this teaching for me in a very concrete and humbling way, and I have a story about that. So one day in the hospital, maybe a few years ago, I was working in the ER and a man was brought in by ambulance. And he was deeply intoxicated. He'd been driving his car. And on the side of the highway, there had been a state police checkpoint. So a couple of police cruisers, officers, and I think someone... that they were checking someone else. And he lost control of his car and smashed into this whole checkpoint. Nobody was killed, which is astonishing. He could have killed several people easily. And so they brought him into us for a medical evaluation to make sure that he was not injured from this collision. And he was put into a room. And he proceeded to scream for fanonies and insults at the nurses. Just constant stream of insults. I could hear him all the way down the hallway. And after a few minutes of this, I could start to feel my blood pressure rising. And I started to get angry. And I was creating a story about this man. It was not a kind story at all. I had a story about his recklessness, his carelessness, his abusiveness towards people who were trying to take care of him. And then finally, it got to the point where I stood up out of my chair and I walked down the hall into the door of his room and raised my voice at him in a very unkind way. It didn't go well. He shouted right back at me. He tried to throw the stretcher at me, but he was handcuffed to it and so it just didn't work. Yeah, it didn't help the situation at all. Like six months later, he checked himself back into the ER and his chief complaint was depression. And I signed up for him, went into his room, sat down, I said, tell me what's going on. And he had a lot to say. He was sober. He told me that he had been in this, he had caused this horrible accident. He had been drinking and driving. He had caused this horrible accident. He hadn't hurt anyone and he was grateful for that, but he had been convicted of whatever crimes he'd been charged with. He'd lost his job. He lost his car. He was awaiting his sentencing and he didn't know how long he'd have to be in jail for and the uncertainty was sort of unbearable for him. He felt like his life was ruined. He had ruined his life. And then he went on. He told me about his childhood. He had grown up with a single mother and there had been substance abuse issues and abusive men and he himself had developed substance use issues. And so this whole other view of his life sort of unspooled in front of me. And I realized at some point that he didn't know who I was. He had been blackout intoxicated when he was there before. He had no memory really of our encounter. But I was able to see him because of the story that he was sharing with me in a wholly new way. And I saw how wrong I'd been. How wrong my story about him had been. And the way that it had become that story that I had allowed to proliferate in my mind had turned into action behavior, which was not in accord with my values. And I saw him with compassion. I mean, what a life he'd been dealt. Really no fault of his own. He'd been through so much. And I was grateful for the opportunity to see him in a more complete light through his own story. And to have the opportunity to apologize to him. I told him, I said, you don't know who I am, do you? And he was like, no. I told him what had happened. And I told him that I was sorry that he didn't deserve to be treated in that way. I feel like it's not often when the world so generously serves you up this sort of educational moment. Show you your own delusion, truth of someone else's suffering, the sort of reflexive compassion that arises when you can see someone in a more complete light. And the opportunity to atone. Very rare. But that was also a story, right? He told me his story. It was more complete than the story I'd told about him. But it was still the story. It wasn't actually his life. It can't be. The story could never be as full or complete as someone's whole life or even one moment. And so a more complete story was helpful. But that actually isn't the most important teaching from this experience for me. I think the most important teaching is that the stories are kind of always beside the point. What that man deserved the first time was to just be met with compassion. No story. Just to have someone see what he was going through and not allow their own story to sort of sweep them away. So Buddhists are really interested in how things really are. It's actually all extremely pragmatic and very concrete. And so many of the early sutras, teachings of the Buddha and his early followers are basically offer sort of intense observations, relentless observations of how our minds actually work and how the world actually is. It's really about seeing things as they truly are. And so early sutras have a lot to say about this because this is the sort of proliferation of story, endlessly complicating itself, which besets the heart. This is an integral part of the human condition. This is just what it's like to be a human. And so the Buddha was interested in this naturally. And so there's a wonderful sutra which was sort of the first teaching on this idea. And the name of the sutra is the Majupindika Sutta, which means something like sweet morsel. And the reason why it was given that name is that it says in the sutra after the Buddha gave a sermon on this topic, which we'll get into a little bit, is disciple Ananda said, Lord, it's as if a man overcome with hunger, weakness, and thirst, to come across a ball of honey, this teaching, a ball of honey. And so the sutra is often called the ball of honey sutra. And the framing that it sets up in the very beginning is that this is about addressing the root of conflict. The root of conflict is what this is about. And it places the concept of Papacha at the center of it. So already that's saying something important. The root of conflict is this endless proliferation, endless complication, endless reification of our own fabrications. So in the sutra, a wanderer named Dandapanen comes across the Buddha sitting in the forest and they lounge together for a little while. And then eventually the wanderer says, Buddha, what is the contemplative doctrine? What is the contemplative doctrine? Buddha says, it's the sort of doctrine where one no longer quarrels with anyone, where perceptions no longer obsess the Brahmin who remains free from perplexity, his uncertainty cut away, devoid of craving for becoming. I'll read that one more time. What is the contemplative doctrine? It's the sort of doctrine where one no longer quarrels with anyone. It's conflict. Where perceptions no longer obsess the person who remains free of perplexity, whose uncertainty is cut away, and who is devoid of craving for becoming. When this was said, the wanderer Dandapanen, this is the actual language in the sutra, shaking his head, wagging his tongue, raising his eyebrows so that his forehead was wrinkled in three furrows left, leaning on his stick. He didn't get it. So animated. So, Chakramuni Buddha goes back to his disciples. He tells them of this encounter. He tells them what was asked, what he responded. And they wondered, but still, what is the doctrine that leads to the end of conflict? They didn't get it either. But the Buddha had gone to bed. And so instead they asked a senior monk named Maha Kajana. And he said, regarding the cause of these thoughts and ideas that assail a person, if they are actually of no substance, then that is the end of taking up rods and bladed weapons of arguments, quarrels, disputes, accusations, divisive speech, and false speech. If they are actually of no substance, that's the end of conflict. This is where these evil, unskillful things cease without remainder. And he goes on. The truth that these thoughts and ideas, these proliferations, are actually of no substance, could be seen in the following way. And then he goes on to explain how the five aggregates sort of assemble and cascade one from the other to create our perception of the world. And so it starts with just our senses. We have our sense organs. The Buddha's number six, number six is the mind. And then there's some sort of stimulus. And then that stimulus, let's say the bell rings. The bell rings, it interacts with my ear, and then there's a sense consciousness of the sound of the bell. That's where it all starts. At that point of contact, when I first hear the bell, some sort of feeling immediately arises. This is the next thing that happens. And the feeling is either positive, negative, or neutral. That's it. Sounds pleasing or harsh. This is a nice bell. Are you going to ring it? Oh, no, but I like that idea. Let's listen. Nice feeling, at least for me. But what happens is when that, and this is a reflexive thing that happens. It's hardwired into our brain. It probably has an adaptive purpose, right? It's like you want to be able to immediately respond on the level of a reflex to something that is either pleasing, good for you, positive, beneficial, or something that is aversive that you might need to run away from. So it happens so fast. It's not conscious. It just immediately we attach some sort of valence to any sort of sense input. But what happens when that happens. Is that what one feels. One perceives and labels in the mind. Then what one perceives one thinks about. This is going back to the language of the sutra. What one thinks about one complicates. Based on what a person complicates, the perceptions and categories of objectification assail them with regard to past, present, and future. This is proliferation. So the five aggregates of experience form sensation, perception, formations, and consciousness. So it goes in that order. Some sort of stimulus, positive, negative feeling. We perceive that feeling. We think about it. We complicate it. So it sort of builds. That's it. That's the stuff of consciousness. There's nothing else from the Buddhist perspective. The trick here is that the presence of feeling something. This goes way back to what's happening on an immediate reflexive level whenever there's a sense input. The feeling that arises suggests that someone is there to do the feeling. It suggests the presence of itself. That's where it starts. From this comes a sense of duality of subject and object. That's the fundamental ingredient for this proliferation. What one thinks about one complicates. That was written several thousand years ago. It feels so right on. Some things haven't changed. Tanasara Bikyu states that the root of Papuncha is the perception, I am the thinker. And from this self-reflexive thought, he says, a number of categories can be derived. Being, not being. Me, not me. Mine, not mine. Do or done to. And from these categories stories arise and proliferate. We can sort of see how the building blocks are all there. Back to the sutra. So the senior monk, Mahakachana says that when we can clearly see that all of the elements of our experience are just these five ingredients tumbling together, flowing like a waterfall. Nothing more. Then we see that there is nothing there to get caught up in, to grasp. So it's about seeing clearly what's actually happening. This is not to say that stories are unnecessary or not useful. This is not an anti-story position. As a physician I use narrative as a kind of