Skip to content
omnism.si

Protestant · Compare this tradition with another

Here We Stand

no name given · St Martin-in-the-Fields London - Sermons und Thought for the Week · 2026-10-19 · London · Source

This text has not been analysed yet.

Show the full text
Orchestra and Shelter St Martin-in-the-Fields is a parish church; but no one would be especially interested in it if it were simply one of 12,500 parish churches in England. St Martin’s is never less than a parish church, but people have been interested in it because for a long time it has generally been much more than a regular parish church. In America, people tend to assume St Martin-in-the-Fields is an orchestra. (When I was living in the United States and was appointed to be vicar of St Martin’s, people approached me and said, ‘I never realised you were so talented musically.’ Of course I smiled, and said, with an assumed bashfulness, ‘Oh well, you know, I wouldn’t say that…’) In the UK, people often think St Martin-in-the-Fields is a homeless centre. The point is, both assumptions have more than an element of truth in them. If you consider St Martin’s as those organisations, both attached to the PCC and independent, that are based on this site, the two charities established to support those experiencing homelessness constitute more than 50% of the turnover of the whole community. Meanwhile of the people who come through these ever-open doors in a year, a larger number come to attend a concert than perhaps anything else. And yet you often hear people say, ‘In the end, we’re a church.’ I think if this is saying, ‘The social outreach and the cultural programme are all very well, but what we’re really here for is to be a church,’ it’s missing the point. What we’re really here for is to challenge and change the whole notion of what a church is. Our social outreach and cultural programme, together with our café and shop, are a big part of that; but they’re not all of it. When people say, ‘What we’re really here for is to be a church,’ I wonder what notion of church is at work in such a statement. Maybe it means worship, maybe it means devotional practices, maybe it means evangelism, maybe it means fellowship, formation, mission, pastoral care, perhaps protest, maybe study. Things pretty much every one of those other 12,500 parish churches around England do. But those activities alone don’t capture what the word ‘church’ means at St Martin’s. At St Martin’s congregation is never isolated from what we call the other three Cs – culture, compassion and commerce. Culture, because the most transformative experience is to be moved by becoming fully alive in creativity and appreciation of the dynamism of others. Compassion, because there’s no greater discovery than the solidarity of being with one another through the most troubled times. Commerce, because keeping the way you generate income as close as possible to the purpose for which you’re generating it is to integrate supporting the community into the mission of the community itself. What’s unique about St Martin’s is that these three things are always part of what we mean by church, and as a result church is never something detached or precious or superior or withdrawn, but always something engaged, invested, energised and, fundamentally, incarnate. Eighty years ago in this country, the state became the church. It took over all the things the church used to do – education, health, welfare, social care. The church thought this was marvellous, and said, ‘The kingdom of God has come.’ But it had signed its own death warrant. Things like hospitals and welfare were much better run by the state. But the problem was, the church started to assume everything should be done by the state. Consequently, the church stopped doing interesting things. And here’s the crucial question. When the church stops doing interesting things, why should anyone be interested in the church? But here’s the secret. St Martin’s was one church that never got the memo. St Martin’s never stopped doing interesting things. (If you doubted that, the magnificent procession of the representatives of those interesting things yesterday at the Tercentenary Celebration demonstrated the breadth of those interesting things.) The result was, people never stopped being interested in St Martin’s. A generation ago, the state stopped wanting to be the church. It realised it was too expensive. Ever since, it’s been looking for ways to back out of those things it took on 80 years ago. And the church was furious, because it had got used to the arrangement, even though it was making the church irrelevant. Now we’re in a time when the government is looking to civil society to embrace and enjoy the possibility of doing interesting things again. And the reason St Martin’s is uniquely placed is because we never stopped. We’re not the only ones by any means who stayed in that space. But St Martin’s never stopped being at the intersection of commerce, culture, compassion and congregational life. Tonight I want to look more closely at what precisely we are trying to be and to do, not just that we might be and do it better, but so we might articulate where we stand so that we might recognise others who do this better than us and so that others again may be inspired to join us. Plato The Greek philosopher Plato, generally regarded as the founder of the Western philosophical tradition, writing 2400 years ago, spoke of three lofty unchanging ‘forms’ beyond the changing material world. Those forms are known as transcendentals. The theologian Thomas Aquinas, writing 800 years ago, adopted Plato’s conception of these three transcendentals, integrating them into Christian theology. What I want to do tonight is to show how these three transcendentals offer a clue to where we stand at St Martin-in-the-Fields. The first of the three transcendentals is goodness. Plato’s Republic is a dialogue between the philosopher Socrates and Plato’s older brother, Glaucon. In Book VII of the Republic , Glaucon tells of Gyges, a shepherd. Gyges finds a bronze ring. Quickly he realises that turning the ring makes him invisible. Accordingly Gyges seduces the queen, murders the king and seizes the throne. Glaucon asks Socrates whether, were one such ring given to a just man and another to an unjust man, both would act in the same way. The question is whether anyone, free from fear of judgement, would simply do as they wished. Is justice only a convention we follow from fear of punishment or loss of reputation, or is it something good in itself? For Socrates, justice is the right ordering of the soul, by which reason rules over appetite and spirit. The unjust person is internally divided and enslaved to his desires, and so is worse off. Goodness is its own reward, because it makes for a healthy soul. Thomas Aquinas modifies this notion of goodness by employing Aristotle’s notion of a telos or end. For Aquinas, goodness is identical to our ultimate purpose. All things desire their ultimate end, and if our ultimate end is goodness, we act according to our nature when we seek to be good. In the words of St Jerome, ‘Begin now to be what you will be hereafter.’ This is how to be good. The second of the three transcendentals is truth. In Book II of the Republic , Socrates tells of a cave in which prisoners have been chained, facing a wall, since childhood. Behind is a fire, and between the fire and the prisoners, people move objects, whose shadows project on the wall. For the prisoners, these shadows are reality. One prisoner is freed and makes his way up out of the cave into sunlight. At first blinded, he gradually sees shadows, reflections, things – and ultimately the sun. He makes his way back down into the cave. But his eyes can’t readjust to the dark, so he stumbles. His former companions dismiss him as foolish, assume the journey ruined his eyesight, and threaten to kill anyone who seeks to free them. Thus Plato portrays truth as requiring a transformation of heart and soul, and a perspective on reality likely to attract the rejection, derision or hostility of those who prefer comfortable illusions. For Aquinas, truth is the moment the human intellect grasps the nature of reality. It needs reality to be comprehensible, and the mind to comprehend it. Thus Jesus is central to truth, not only because he points to the ultimate reality of the Trinity, but because being in human form, he enables us to grasp that reality. The third of the three transcendentals is beauty. In Plato’s Symposium , Socrates says love is a longing for what is beautiful and good, and it can be understood as a step-by-step ascent. When you love erotically you become fixated on one beautiful body. But you may then find the beauty you see or imagine in this body is the same as the beauty in many other bodies, and you become less obsessed with the one. Then you may begin to cherish the beauty of a soul above that of a body, and the beauty of laws and institutions even more so, and the beauty of knowledge above them all. Finally you may behold beauty itself – eternal, unchanging, pure, ‘unmixed with human flesh and colour.’ Thus beauty and attraction are a doorway that leads toward the source of all beauty. For Aquinas, beauty is something apprehended beyond appetite or desire, and crystallises around completeness, harmony, and splendour. Where Plato and Thomas Aquinas agree is in the inseparability of goodness, truth and beauty. For Aquinas, they are different ways of perceiving or describing the same fundamental reality. For something to be genuinely good, it must be beautiful and true as well. For something to be genuinely beautiful, it must be good and true as well. For something to be genuinely truthful, it must be good and beautiful as well. The Disconnected World Now I want to step away from the exalted realm of transcendentals for a moment and re-enter the world of earthly realities with which we began. I want to suggest that our everyday experience is of a disconnected world. By this I mean a world where these three transcendentals have become detached from one another, like three parts of a spacecraft drifting apart in the stratosphere, or at least attenuated, so one has come to be prioritised, and the others relegated to the background. Let me start with goodness. Seventeen hundred years ago, in 337, a soldier named Martin saw a beggar by the gates of Amiens. He dismounted his horse, tore his cloak in two, and gave half to the beggar. That night he dreamed the beggar was Christ. Martin later became a monk and then a bishop, and St Martin of Tours was among the most popular saints of the Middle Ages, giving his name to so many churches that they needed nicknames to tell them apart; including this one, which in the thirteenth century was in the fields. But what Martin did outside Amiens in 337 was to invent the modern notion of charity. Charity is the sense of obligation one has to a person who is not your friend of family member, and the sense of joy derived from turning pity and shame into dignity and respect. There was no such notion in the fourth century. The social outreach work for which this community has long been famous is about enshrining this same notion of charity. It’s no exaggeration to say the healthy standing this community has in the conscience of this nation is largely due to its being synonymous with doing practical good. Charities are complementary to government because charities pay for things for which a majority in a democracy would not vote. Goodness only goes wrong or remains unfulfilled when it forgets about truth and beauty. Goodness forgets about truth when it makes absurd claims or sets meaningless targets. It was perhaps noble and rhetorically powerful but nonetheless inviting scepticism to urge people to Make Poverty History. There will always be poverty; there are some things we rightly long and strive to alleviate, even though we know they can’t be completely eradicated by bureaucratic management or passionate care. Goodness is less about grand gestures than small fidelities. It’s not about doing great things but doing small things with great love. It recognises with humility its limited scope and enjoys the corresponding freedom to set achievable rather than inflated goals. Goodness may also forget about truth when it gives in to despair, and sees charity as a tragic gesture in the face of bleakness and sorrow; or when it is content to judge and condemn others, rather than see its own shortcomings. St Martin’s is not a community that thinks the world’s going to hell in a handbasket, and all we can do is to try to make a few lives better while everything collapses around us. St Martin’s is instead a community that believes it’s better to fail in a cause that will finally succeed, than to succeed in a cause that will finally fail. The conviction that the cause will finally succeed – the trust that neither we nor the forces against us have the last word, but that God has the last word and that word is love: that conviction is called hope, and hope is the way we ultimately invest in truth. Goodness can also lose sight of truth when it’s tempted to exaggerate information or falsify communication to provide evidence of people’s plight or boast about one’s success in addressing it. The truth will set you free, said Jesus: in the end exaggeration and falsification, along with sentimentality, get in the way of true goodness rather than advancing it. Goodness forgets about beauty when it gets into a mindset that the flourishing of everyone requires the punishment of some or the dismantling of joy. There’s a culture at large that suggests you prove your righteousness by the extent of your anger. There’s a place for anger. Anger can stir us from distraction or self-absorption to an acute awareness of wrong done. When directed away from our own pride, and towards another’s well-being, anger can be a means to a healthy end, like a ladder we can kick away once we’re truly engaged in seeking the good. But rage names the moment we decouple from our rational faculties. We lose sight of the original wrong done in our rampaging quest for destruction and vengeance. In our outrage we tell ourselves we can and should destroy all in our path, for only then can justice be restored and fury satisfied. Rage is the point where anger and goodness part company, truth is left behind, and beauty is lost altogether. Anger can lead towards reason and eventually justice; rage, to neither. I wonder whether anger and rage are a way we prove to ourselves and to others that our lives matter (and are not hopelessly compromised) because we care so much. Goodness more obviously forgets about beauty when it imagines something is inherently bad because it is expensive. I recall going through a period myself as a young man when I was so furious about inequality that I couldn’t go in a place like the National Gallery because I thought all the pictures and the building should be sold to provide more resources and opportunities for socially disadvantaged people. But then I realised I had fallen into thinking beauty, and God, were in short supply, and had to be rationed. I came to understand the National Gallery is for everybody, no one has to pay, each person entering can find their soul lifted, their heart stirred and their existence ennobled by being there. Economic status is important, but doesn’t define a person; lose sight of creativity, wonder, joy, inspiration, art and beauty, and you don’t make anyone’s life better – you just impoverish everyone. I came to realise you can’t always make things happy, but you can still make them beautiful; this has remained my life’s motto ever since. Turning to truth, it’s helpful to recognise different kinds of truth. Keeping it simple, we may start with objective truth, which can be proved empirically by repeated observation, calibrated measurement and universal recognition, or rationally by logic. We then have normative truth, which is what a given group of people agree to recognise. Subjective truth is my truth – an account of how I see and experience and judge things, regardless of whether anyone else does. We could add complex truth, which adapts to whichever truth is most appropriate, for example objective in a scientific conference, normative in a court of law, and subjective in a therapist’s consultation. What’s happened to theological truth is that for centuries it was regarded as objective truth; then it became treated as subjective truth which was neither suitable to be imposed on others nor objectively valid and thus good only for personal comfort and devotion; while all along it might have been better treated as normative truth, which provided the purpose, logic and narrative behind the habits, customs and identity of a people. Truth goes wrong or remains unfulfilled when it forgets about goodness and beauty. Truth forgets about goodness when it overlooks the principle that virtues hunt in packs. Legend has it that Bessie Braddock said, ‘Mr Churchill, you’re drunk.’ Winston Churchill replied, ‘Miss Braddock, you’re ugly. But in the morning, I will be sober.’ When you say to someone, ‘You’re ugly,’ it sounds like an objective statement against a standard that of course does not exist; it could be a normative statement in relation to a convention of measurements of beauty according to age, figure, features and charm; but in fact, it’s simply a subjective judgement. The point is, whichever kind of truth it claims to represent, expressing it shows a lack of kindness, gentleness, patience, timeliness, thoughtfulness, and love. Likewise, when we say, ‘I’m just saying,’ we’re often claiming the right to express a truth without taking responsibility for creating an appropriate context in which to share that truth. Even more problematic is ‘I’m just asking the question,’ which is similar but worse because we’re not even owning that we regard our statement as true, and instead hiding behind an attitude of provocation. Truth can be significantly about tone of voice. I sense something like this has been at work in controversies within the church in recent decades. It’s possible to say, ‘This is true,’ claiming objective or at least normative authority, and failing to take account of how deeply the claim or ruling damages or inhibits the lives of countless people who themselves are perceiving a different kind of truth. This is truth without goodness or beauty; and the church has increasingly come to realise truth without goodness or beauty perhaps isn’t actually truth at all. Truth forgets about beauty when it lapses into utilitarian or procedural assumptions and loses sight of an aesthetic or cosmic context. I think of a phrase common in management consultancy settings: ‘What’s the problem we’re trying to fix here?’ Such an approach to life, which sees itself as a bomb disposal squad proceeding down a military path seeking to defuse or dismantle assorted landmines, shrinks the glorious diversity, extent and complexity of our existence down to a narrow story of jeopardy and solution. Beauty is about so much more. It’s about our smallness in the vast universe, about the juxtaposition of contrasting things that bring out qualities in each other that wouldn’t otherwise surface, about awe and wonder and the gasp of overwhelming, about the beyond, the energising, the moving and the inspirational. I have a friend who likes to say, ‘If a thing’s worth doing, it’s worth doing badly.’ We might say, ‘If a thing’s worth doing, it’s worth doing with grace, gentleness, dexterity, gratitude and generosity.’ Beauty doesn’t always have to be the noun; it can be content to be the adjective. Just don’t ever think you can leave it out and still articulate the truth. And so to beauty itself. I think of three kinds of beauty. There’s prophetic beauty, which stirs, surprises and sometimes shocks. Prophetic beauty contrasts the way the world is with the way it could or should be, and either protests at the shortfall or points to the possibility of transformation. Then there’s priestly beauty, which inspires, connects, transcends and connects with the holy, i