Asked “Where does the evil reside?”, 19 of 25 traditions give the same answer: in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual.
The twelve values say what stance a text takes. The sixteen areas of life say what it speaks about. Both stay on the surface. An address about giving and a prosperity gospel both land on "money: framed as a good", for opposite reasons.
This page asks underneath. Eight questions that can be put to every tradition in the same words. What is measured is what the text claims, not whether it is right: "in need of redemption" is a statement about how a text sees things, not about people.
On 3 of the eight questions, at least two thirds of the traditions with enough texts give the same answer. What counts is each tradition's most frequent answer, and only traditions with at least five analysed texts are counted.
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Sunni | Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 44 %; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 35 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 20 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 16 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 12 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 10 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 5 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 5 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 4 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 4 % | 297 texts |
| Orthodox (Christianity) | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 32 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 25 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 17 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 17 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 13 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 11 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 10 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 7 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 4 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 0 % | 254 texts |
| Protestant | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 38 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 30 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 17 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 17 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 15 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 14 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 11 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 8 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 7 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 4 % | 149 texts |
| Climate movement | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 66 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 50 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 38 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 8 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 6 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 1 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 1 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 1 % | 148 texts |
| Catholic | Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 32 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 28 %; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 28 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 23 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 17 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 14 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 9 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 6 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 4 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 2 % | 145 texts |
| Free church | Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 37 %; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 33 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 19 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 16 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 14 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 13 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 12 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 8 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 2 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 1 % | 129 texts |
| Humanist | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 68 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 33 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 26 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 6 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 6 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 3 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 3 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 1 % | 117 texts |
| Theravada | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 77 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 77 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 12 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 8 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 5 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 2 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 1 % | 111 texts |
| Queer community | Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 43 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 43 %; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 42 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 33 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 5 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 2 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 1 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 1 % | 84 texts |
| Hinduism | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 66 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 60 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 12 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 6 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 4 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 3 % | 77 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Judaism | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 49 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 31 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 15 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 14 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 7 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 5 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 3 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 3 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 3 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 2 % | 59 texts |
| Zen | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 91 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 65 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 11 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 4 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 2 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 2 % | 55 texts |
| Vaishnava | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 75 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 33 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 15 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 5 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 5 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 4 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 2 % | 55 texts |
| Orthodox (Judaism) | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 30 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 28 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 15 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 13 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 13 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 9 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 9 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 7 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 4 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 4 % | 46 texts |
| Reform | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 28 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 18 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 18 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 13 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 13 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 10 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 8 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 8 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 5 % | 39 texts |
| Mahayana | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 70 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 68 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 11 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 11 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 11 % | 37 texts |
| Shia | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 41 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 34 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 25 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 16 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 16 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 9 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 9 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 6 % | 32 texts |
| Sikhism | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 56 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 38 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 28 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 19 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 9 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 6 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 3 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 3 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 3 % | 32 texts |
| Ahmadiyya | Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 58 %; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 31 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 23 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 19 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 15 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 8 %; Sin, personal failure, guilt before God 8 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 4 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 4 % | 26 texts |
| Baha'i | Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 28 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 24 %; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 20 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 16 %; Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry 8 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 4 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 4 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 4 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 4 % | 25 texts |
| Tibetan | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 80 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 47 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 13 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 13 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 7 % | 15 texts |
| Buddhism | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 77 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 38 %; Clinging, desire, the inability to let go 23 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 23 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 15 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 8 % | 13 texts |
| Alevi | Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 73 %; Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions 45 %; Pressure on one's own community from outside 36 %; Greed, consumption, an insatiable desire for more 9 %; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 9 % | 11 texts |
| Philosophical | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 67 %; Emptiness, a lack of direction, despair 22 %; Illness, death, and transience as the fundamental problem 11 % | 9 texts |
| Conservative | Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality 100 %; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community 20 % | 5 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Sunni | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 78 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 7 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 6 %; with a named other group 4 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 3 % | 297 texts |
| Orthodox (Christianity) | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 53 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 13 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 10 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 9 %; with a named other group 4 % | 254 texts |
| Protestant | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 60 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 23 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 9 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 7 % | 149 texts |
| Climate movement | in the economy, politics, or social structures 99 %; with a named other group 1 % | 148 texts |
| Catholic | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 56 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 18 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 13 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 11 %; with a named other group 1 % | 145 texts |
| Free church | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 70 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 17 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 9 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 4 % | 129 texts |
| Humanist | in the economy, politics, or social structures 80 %; in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 6 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 5 %; with a named other group 4 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 2 % | 117 texts |
| Theravada | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 95 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 2 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 2 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 1 % | 111 texts |
| Queer community | in the economy, politics, or social structures 82 %; with a named other group 7 %; in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 6 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 5 % | 84 texts |
| Hinduism | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 100 % | 77 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Judaism | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 63 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 19 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 12 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 3 %; with a named other group 2 % | 59 texts |
| Zen | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 91 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 9 % | 55 texts |
| Vaishnava | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 91 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 4 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 4 % | 55 texts |
| Orthodox (Judaism) | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 65 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 17 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 9 %; with a named other group 7 % | 46 texts |
| Reform | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 41 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 28 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 21 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 3 % | 39 texts |
| Mahayana | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 92 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 3 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 3 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 3 % | 37 texts |
| Shia | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 41 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 28 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 9 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 9 %; with a named other group 6 % | 32 texts |
| Sikhism | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 34 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 22 %; with a named other group 19 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 16 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 3 % | 32 texts |
| Ahmadiyya | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 69 %; with a named other group 19 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 8 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 4 % | 26 texts |
| Baha'i | in the economy, politics, or social structures 40 %; in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 32 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 8 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 4 % | 25 texts |
| Tibetan | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 67 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 20 %; with a named other group 7 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 7 % | 15 texts |
| Buddhism | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 62 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 23 %; in the economy, politics, or social structures 15 % | 13 texts |
| Alevi | in the economy, politics, or social structures 91 %; in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 9 % | 11 texts |
| Philosophical | in the economy, politics, or social structures 56 %; in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age 22 %; with a named other group 11 %; in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 11 % | 9 texts |
| Conservative | in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual 80 %; in one's own congregation, family, or religion 20 % | 5 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Sunni | practical action towards the neighbour, good works 32 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 31 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 30 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 28 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 27 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 24 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 9 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 8 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 6 %; just social or political conditions 2 % | 297 texts |
| Orthodox (Christianity) | solidarity, mutual help, belonging 42 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 26 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 26 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 25 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 24 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 21 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 13 %; just social or political conditions 5 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 4 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 1 % | 254 texts |
| Protestant | personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 41 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 39 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 34 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 30 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 25 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 12 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 8 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 3 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 1 %; just social or political conditions 1 % | 149 texts |
| Climate movement | practical action towards the neighbour, good works 78 %; just social or political conditions 57 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 30 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 21 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 3 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 3 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 1 % | 148 texts |
| Catholic | solidarity, mutual help, belonging 43 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 30 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 30 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 29 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 28 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 21 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 9 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 6 %; just social or political conditions 2 % | 145 texts |
| Free church | personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 44 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 38 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 31 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 25 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 23 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 20 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 12 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 3 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 1 %; just social or political conditions 1 % | 129 texts |
| Humanist | insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 67 %; just social or political conditions 56 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 26 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 16 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 5 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 3 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 3 % | 117 texts |
| Theravada | insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 73 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 70 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 25 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 14 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 6 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 6 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 2 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 1 % | 111 texts |
| Queer community | just social or political conditions 45 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 45 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 42 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 39 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 10 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 2 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 2 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 2 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 1 % | 84 texts |
| Hinduism | insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 60 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 52 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 27 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 22 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 12 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 10 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 6 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 4 %; just social or political conditions 1 % | 77 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Judaism | inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 36 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 36 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 31 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 29 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 24 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 19 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 17 %; just social or political conditions 5 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 2 % | 59 texts |
| Zen | prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 69 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 56 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 20 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 18 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 18 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 7 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 7 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 2 % | 55 texts |
| Vaishnava | insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 73 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 40 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 24 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 20 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 15 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 9 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 7 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 5 % | 55 texts |
| Orthodox (Judaism) | solidarity, mutual help, belonging 41 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 33 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 30 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 26 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 22 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 17 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 17 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 9 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 4 % | 46 texts |
| Reform | solidarity, mutual help, belonging 38 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 36 %; just social or political conditions 21 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 18 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 15 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 15 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 15 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 15 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 8 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 3 % | 39 texts |
| Mahayana | insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 68 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 51 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 19 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 19 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 14 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 11 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 11 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 5 % | 37 texts |
| Shia | insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 66 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 38 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 31 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 22 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 9 %; just social or political conditions 9 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 6 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 6 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 3 % | 32 texts |
| Sikhism | insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 53 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 44 %; just social or political conditions 28 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 19 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 16 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 16 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 9 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 6 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 3 % | 32 texts |
| Ahmadiyya | inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 46 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 27 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 27 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 27 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 23 %; contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go 19 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 15 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 8 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 4 %; just social or political conditions 4 % | 26 texts |
| Baha'i | solidarity, mutual help, belonging 64 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 48 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 36 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 16 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 12 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 8 %; God's grace, redemption that is not deserved 4 %; just social or political conditions 4 % | 25 texts |
| Tibetan | insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 73 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 47 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 27 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 27 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 13 %; just social or political conditions 7 % | 15 texts |
| Buddhism | insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 69 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 54 %; practical action towards the neighbour, good works 31 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 15 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 15 %; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind 8 % | 13 texts |
| Alevi | practical action towards the neighbour, good works 64 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 45 %; just social or political conditions 45 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 18 %; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 18 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 9 % | 11 texts |
| Philosophical | insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 100 %; just social or political conditions 22 %; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people 11 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 11 % | 9 texts |
| Conservative | insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding 100 %; keeping the commandments, maintaining order, fulfiling one's duties 60 %; solidarity, mutual help, belonging 20 %; prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice 20 % | 5 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Sunni | willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 71 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 11 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 8 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 5 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 3 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 1 % | 297 texts |
| Orthodox (Christianity) | fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 38 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 24 %; willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 22 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 4 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 3 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 2 % | 254 texts |
| Protestant | fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 30 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 23 %; willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 20 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 11 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 9 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 5 % | 149 texts |
| Climate movement | self-determined, the author of one's own actions 71 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 26 %; willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 1 % | 148 texts |
| Catholic | willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 36 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 23 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 22 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 12 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 4 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 1 % | 145 texts |
| Free church | fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 40 %; willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 27 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 13 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 12 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 4 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 3 % | 129 texts |
| Humanist | self-determined, the author of one's own actions 88 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 7 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 2 %; willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 1 % | 117 texts |
| Theravada | entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 90 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 5 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 3 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 1 %; willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 1 % | 111 texts |
| Queer community | self-determined, the author of one's own actions 61 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 24 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 5 %; willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 5 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 5 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 1 % | 84 texts |
| Hinduism | entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 75 %; willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 8 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 6 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 5 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 4 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 1 % | 77 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Judaism | willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 47 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 29 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 15 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 3 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 3 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 2 % | 59 texts |
| Zen | entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 87 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 11 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 2 % | 55 texts |
| Vaishnava | entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 40 %; willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 31 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 11 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 7 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 5 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 5 % | 55 texts |
| Orthodox (Judaism) | willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 46 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 20 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 13 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 11 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 7 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 4 % | 46 texts |
| Reform | willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 38 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 31 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 21 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 3 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 3 % | 39 texts |
| Mahayana | entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 62 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 14 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 11 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 8 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 3 %; willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 3 % | 37 texts |
| Shia | willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 59 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 16 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 9 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 6 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 3 % | 32 texts |
| Sikhism | above all a part of a community or of creation 56 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 19 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 9 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 9 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 6 % | 32 texts |
| Ahmadiyya | willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 77 %; fallen, not able to be made whole by one's own strength 8 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 8 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 8 % | 26 texts |
| Baha'i | willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 44 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 44 %; described above all as one who is accepted and given to 8 % | 25 texts |
| Tibetan | entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 67 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 27 % | 15 texts |
| Buddhism | entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 54 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 31 %; self-determined, the author of one's own actions 15 % | 13 texts |
| Alevi | self-determined, the author of one's own actions 64 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 36 % | 11 texts |
| Philosophical | self-determined, the author of one's own actions 67 %; entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free 22 %; above all a part of a community or of creation 11 % | 9 texts |
| Conservative | self-determined, the author of one's own actions 80 %; willed by God, with a task and a responsibility 20 % | 5 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Sunni | the message stands outside of history 53 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 12 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 12 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 8 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 4 % | 297 texts |
| Orthodox (Christianity) | the message stands outside of history 36 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 24 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 13 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 10 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 7 % | 254 texts |
| Protestant | a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 48 %; the message stands outside of history 28 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 16 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 5 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 2 % | 149 texts |
| Climate movement | it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 68 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 26 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 3 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 1 % | 148 texts |
| Catholic | a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 55 %; the message stands outside of history 19 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 14 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 4 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 1 % | 145 texts |
| Free church | a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 47 %; the message stands outside of history 23 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 14 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 8 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 2 % | 129 texts |
| Humanist | it is getting better, development towards the good 45 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 44 %; the message stands outside of history 3 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 1 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 1 % | 117 texts |
| Theravada | the message stands outside of history 59 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 20 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 6 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 4 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 1 % | 111 texts |
| Queer community | it is getting better, development towards the good 57 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 31 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 5 %; the message stands outside of history 2 % | 84 texts |
| Hinduism | the message stands outside of history 73 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 13 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 8 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 1 % | 77 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Judaism | the message stands outside of history 32 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 25 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 22 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 7 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 7 % | 59 texts |
| Zen | the message stands outside of history 55 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 27 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 7 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 4 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 4 % | 55 texts |
| Vaishnava | the message stands outside of history 60 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 11 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 7 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 4 % | 55 texts |
| Orthodox (Judaism) | the message stands outside of history 33 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 20 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 15 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 15 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 2 % | 46 texts |
| Reform | the message stands outside of history 41 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 18 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 10 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 8 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 5 % | 39 texts |
| Mahayana | recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 43 %; the message stands outside of history 27 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 14 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 3 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 3 % | 37 texts |
| Shia | the message stands outside of history 44 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 16 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 12 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 12 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 6 % | 32 texts |
| Sikhism | the message stands outside of history 38 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 25 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 19 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 6 % | 32 texts |
| Ahmadiyya | the message stands outside of history 54 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 19 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 15 % | 26 texts |
| Baha'i | it is getting better, development towards the good 72 %; the message stands outside of history 8 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 4 % | 25 texts |
| Tibetan | recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 40 %; the message stands outside of history 27 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 13 %; a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 7 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 7 % | 15 texts |
| Buddhism | the message stands outside of history 46 %; it is getting better, development towards the good 38 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 15 % | 13 texts |
| Alevi | it is getting better, development towards the good 82 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 9 %; the message stands outside of history 9 % | 11 texts |
| Philosophical | it is getting better, development towards the good 56 %; recurrence, no goal, always the same pattern 22 %; it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end 11 % | 9 texts |
| Conservative | a turning point, a coming, a new order is about to arrive 20 % | 5 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Sunni | on the founder or prophet of the tradition 85 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 83 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 18 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 3 %; on argument, logic, science 2 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 2 % | 297 texts |
| Orthodox (Christianity) | on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 72 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 46 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 31 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 19 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 12 %; on argument, logic, science 8 % | 254 texts |
| Protestant | on the holy scripture of its own tradition 82 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 46 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 30 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 11 %; on argument, logic, science 7 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 2 % | 149 texts |
| Climate movement | on argument, logic, science 91 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 52 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 6 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 4 % | 148 texts |
| Catholic | on the holy scripture of its own tradition 72 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 41 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 36 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 19 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 19 %; on argument, logic, science 2 % | 145 texts |
| Free church | on the holy scripture of its own tradition 88 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 38 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 25 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 11 %; on argument, logic, science 5 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 5 % | 129 texts |
| Humanist | on argument, logic, science 95 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 35 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 6 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 4 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 1 % | 117 texts |
| Theravada | on personal experience, testimony, encounter 67 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 58 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 41 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 8 %; on argument, logic, science 5 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 5 % | 111 texts |
| Queer community | on personal experience, testimony, encounter 76 %; on argument, logic, science 65 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 12 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 4 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 4 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 1 % | 84 texts |
| Hinduism | on the holy scripture of its own tradition 60 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 44 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 36 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 18 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 17 %; on argument, logic, science 4 % | 77 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Judaism | on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 73 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 64 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 15 %; on argument, logic, science 14 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 8 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 5 % | 59 texts |
| Zen | on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 53 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 51 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 42 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 27 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 9 %; on argument, logic, science 5 % | 55 texts |
| Vaishnava | on the holy scripture of its own tradition 87 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 49 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 18 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 11 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 11 %; on argument, logic, science 11 % | 55 texts |
| Orthodox (Judaism) | on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 72 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 70 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 26 %; on argument, logic, science 7 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 4 % | 46 texts |
| Reform | on the holy scripture of its own tradition 77 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 67 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 23 %; on argument, logic, science 13 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 3 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 3 % | 39 texts |
| Mahayana | on the founder or prophet of the tradition 73 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 38 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 35 %; on argument, logic, science 19 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 14 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 11 % | 37 texts |
| Shia | on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 72 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 59 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 28 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 19 %; on argument, logic, science 12 % | 32 texts |
| Sikhism | on the holy scripture of its own tradition 47 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 41 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 31 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 28 %; on argument, logic, science 22 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 9 % | 32 texts |
| Ahmadiyya | on the founder or prophet of the tradition 73 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 46 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 35 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 27 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 12 %; on argument, logic, science 4 % | 26 texts |
| Baha'i | on the founder or prophet of the tradition 56 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 48 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 28 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 24 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 12 %; on argument, logic, science 8 % | 25 texts |
| Tibetan | on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 80 %; on a present head, teacher, or office 47 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 40 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 20 %; on personal experience, testimony, encounter 13 % | 15 texts |
| Buddhism | on personal experience, testimony, encounter 77 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 77 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 31 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 8 %; on argument, logic, science 8 % | 13 texts |
| Alevi | on personal experience, testimony, encounter 73 %; on argument, logic, science 55 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 36 %; on the founder or prophet of the tradition 9 % | 11 texts |
| Philosophical | on argument, logic, science 100 %; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 11 % | 9 texts |
| Conservative | on tradition, the fathers, an established practice 80 %; on the holy scripture of its own tradition 20 %; on argument, logic, science 20 % | 5 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Sunni | to one's own fellow believers 82 %; to every human being, regardless of faith 14 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 2 %; also to kindred traditions, but not to all 1 % | 297 texts |
| Orthodox (Christianity) | to one's own fellow believers 65 %; to every human being, regardless of faith 28 %; also to kindred traditions, but not to all 5 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 0 % | 254 texts |
| Protestant | to every human being, regardless of faith 53 %; to one's own fellow believers 38 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 6 %; also to kindred traditions, but not to all 3 % | 149 texts |
| Climate movement | to every human being, regardless of faith 52 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 44 %; to one's own fellow believers 2 %; also to kindred traditions, but not to all 1 % | 148 texts |
| Catholic | to one's own fellow believers 49 %; to every human being, regardless of faith 44 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 6 %; also to kindred traditions, but not to all 1 % | 145 texts |
| Free church | to one's own fellow believers 71 %; to every human being, regardless of faith 29 % | 129 texts |
| Humanist | to every human being, regardless of faith 90 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 5 %; to one's own fellow believers 2 % | 117 texts |
| Theravada | to every human being, regardless of faith 71 %; to one's own fellow believers 23 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 6 % | 111 texts |
| Queer community | to every human being, regardless of faith 77 %; to one's own fellow believers 19 %; also to kindred traditions, but not to all 2 % | 84 texts |
| Hinduism | to every human being, regardless of faith 83 %; to one's own fellow believers 9 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 8 % | 77 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Judaism | to one's own fellow believers 64 %; to every human being, regardless of faith 31 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 5 % | 59 texts |
| Zen | to every human being, regardless of faith 58 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 24 %; to one's own fellow believers 18 % | 55 texts |
| Vaishnava | to every human being, regardless of faith 62 %; to one's own fellow believers 35 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 2 % | 55 texts |
| Orthodox (Judaism) | to one's own fellow believers 59 %; to every human being, regardless of faith 41 % | 46 texts |
| Reform | to one's own fellow believers 62 %; to every human being, regardless of faith 33 % | 39 texts |
| Mahayana | to every human being, regardless of faith 95 %; to one's own fellow believers 5 % | 37 texts |
| Shia | to one's own fellow believers 69 %; to every human being, regardless of faith 25 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 3 %; also to kindred traditions, but not to all 3 % | 32 texts |
| Sikhism | to one's own fellow believers 75 %; to every human being, regardless of faith 19 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 6 % | 32 texts |
| Ahmadiyya | to one's own fellow believers 73 %; to every human being, regardless of faith 23 %; also to kindred traditions, but not to all 4 % | 26 texts |
| Baha'i | to every human being, regardless of faith 64 %; to one's own fellow believers 32 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 4 % | 25 texts |
| Tibetan | to one's own fellow believers 40 %; to every human being, regardless of faith 33 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 13 %; also to kindred traditions, but not to all 13 % | 15 texts |
| Buddhism | to every human being, regardless of faith 69 %; also to animals, plants, and all of creation 23 %; to one's own fellow believers 8 % | 13 texts |
| Alevi | to every human being, regardless of faith 82 %; to one's own fellow believers 18 % | 11 texts |
| Philosophical | to every human being, regardless of faith 100 % | 9 texts |
| Conservative | to one's own fellow believers 100 % | 5 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Sunni | at one's own community and at oneself 75 %; at others, at society, at other groups 11 %; the text does not criticise 8 %; explicitly at both 6 % | 297 texts |
| Orthodox (Christianity) | at one's own community and at oneself 40 %; the text does not criticise 33 %; at others, at society, at other groups 23 %; explicitly at both 3 % | 254 texts |
| Protestant | at one's own community and at oneself 58 %; at others, at society, at other groups 16 %; explicitly at both 13 %; the text does not criticise 13 % | 149 texts |
| Climate movement | at others, at society, at other groups 97 %; explicitly at both 2 %; the text does not criticise 1 %; at one's own community and at oneself 1 % | 148 texts |
| Catholic | at one's own community and at oneself 54 %; the text does not criticise 17 %; explicitly at both 16 %; at others, at society, at other groups 13 % | 145 texts |
| Free church | at one's own community and at oneself 71 %; the text does not criticise 18 %; at others, at society, at other groups 9 %; explicitly at both 3 % | 129 texts |
| Humanist | at others, at society, at other groups 81 %; the text does not criticise 13 %; explicitly at both 4 %; at one's own community and at oneself 2 % | 117 texts |
| Theravada | at one's own community and at oneself 87 %; the text does not criticise 6 %; at others, at society, at other groups 5 %; explicitly at both 2 % | 111 texts |
| Queer community | at others, at society, at other groups 79 %; the text does not criticise 11 %; at one's own community and at oneself 7 %; explicitly at both 4 % | 84 texts |
| Hinduism | at one's own community and at oneself 81 %; the text does not criticise 18 %; at others, at society, at other groups 1 % | 77 texts |
| Tradition | What the texts say | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Judaism | at one's own community and at oneself 66 %; at others, at society, at other groups 17 %; the text does not criticise 14 %; explicitly at both 3 % | 59 texts |
| Zen | at one's own community and at oneself 87 %; the text does not criticise 5 %; at others, at society, at other groups 5 %; explicitly at both 2 % | 55 texts |
| Vaishnava | at one's own community and at oneself 78 %; the text does not criticise 15 %; at others, at society, at other groups 5 %; explicitly at both 2 % | 55 texts |
| Orthodox (Judaism) | at one's own community and at oneself 61 %; the text does not criticise 24 %; at others, at society, at other groups 11 %; explicitly at both 4 % | 46 texts |
| Reform | at one's own community and at oneself 46 %; the text does not criticise 28 %; at others, at society, at other groups 21 %; explicitly at both 5 % | 39 texts |
| Mahayana | at one's own community and at oneself 73 %; the text does not criticise 16 %; at others, at society, at other groups 8 %; explicitly at both 3 % | 37 texts |
| Shia | at one's own community and at oneself 44 %; at others, at society, at other groups 28 %; the text does not criticise 25 %; explicitly at both 3 % | 32 texts |
| Sikhism | at others, at society, at other groups 41 %; at one's own community and at oneself 41 %; the text does not criticise 12 %; explicitly at both 6 % | 32 texts |
| Ahmadiyya | at one's own community and at oneself 58 %; at others, at society, at other groups 31 %; explicitly at both 8 %; the text does not criticise 4 % | 26 texts |
| Baha'i | the text does not criticise 60 %; at one's own community and at oneself 20 %; at others, at society, at other groups 16 %; explicitly at both 4 % | 25 texts |
| Tibetan | at one's own community and at oneself 40 %; the text does not criticise 33 %; at others, at society, at other groups 27 % | 15 texts |
| Buddhism | at one's own community and at oneself 46 %; the text does not criticise 31 %; at others, at society, at other groups 15 %; explicitly at both 8 % | 13 texts |
| Alevi | at others, at society, at other groups 82 %; the text does not criticise 9 %; at one's own community and at oneself 9 % | 11 texts |
| Philosophical | at others, at society, at other groups 56 %; the text does not criticise 33 %; at one's own community and at oneself 11 % | 9 texts |
| Conservative | the text does not criticise 80 %; at one's own community and at oneself 20 % | 5 texts |
A text that states its diagnosis is a different thing from one where it has to be inferred. Every assignment therefore carries a note about that. A question stays empty when the text offers nothing on it. A gap is better than a guessed answer. 1 = inferred, the text does not say it explicitly, 2 = clearly discernible, 3 = stated explicitly, central to the text.