omnist.world

Deutsch

Sunni · Compare this tradition with another

Novel Company

no name given · Jamiatul Ulama KZN – Council of Muslim Theologians (Suedafrika) · 2026-09-16 · Durban · Source

Responsibility · main message Repentance · carrying Knowledge · carrying

Reading novels and consuming modern media harms the reader's mind, because stories shape the brain and behavior, and should be replaced by reciting the Quran and reading Islamic books.

Stories shape our lives and in some cases help to define a person.

The text uses a hadith parable about good and bad friends to illustrate the influence of company on a person. It extends the concept of company to reading novels and cites a neurological study showing that stories can influence the brain and behavior. The author argues that novels with materialistic and sexually indecent content harm the reader's mind and lead to sinful behavior. He refers to the time that is not used for reciting the Quran due to reading novels, and names blogs, films, and social media as even more harmful modern forms. The text advises instead reading Islamic books under the guidance of an alim and reciting the Quran daily. The central message is that one should consciously choose one's mental 'company' and that the Quran is the best company.

Worldview

what this means
What, according to this text, is the root of the evil?
Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality
Where does the evil reside?
in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual
What helps against it?
prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding
What is human being according to this text?
entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free
Where is history heading?
it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end
What does the text base its claim on?
on tradition, the fathers, an established practice; on argument, logic, science
To whom does the text's call for devotion apply?
to one's own fellow believers
Where is the text's criticism directed?
at one's own community and at oneself

Related texts from other traditions

by similarity of the analysis, one text per tradition

What the text calls for

Passages cited

Hadith (Parfümhändler und Schmied)

Measured

Basic stance
-1 from -2 to 2
Insistence
3 of 3
Reach
1 of 5
Concreteness
3 of 3
Boundary
1 of 3
Time
past 1, present 3, future 2

Analysed with qwen3.8-27b, version v3. The same standards apply to every tradition, see Values.

Show the full text
alhaadi.org A beautiful parable in the hadith compares a good friend with a perfume seller and a bad friend with a blacksmith. The least benefit one will acquire in the company of a perfume seller is that one will certainly get the beautiful scent of perfume, which will freshen the mind and heart. Likewise, a good friend will always be a means of benefit. Merely being in his company will incline the heart towards good. On the contrary the least harm in the company of a blacksmith is that one will breathe the toxic smoke that will be all around his environment. Likewise the company of a bad friend is spiritually toxic. Merely being in bad company will influence one towards evil and sin. STORIES SHAPE LIVES While human companionship will generally have the greatest effect and influence on one, the company one keeps is much broader than being in the company of friends and associates. Many people spend long hours in the company of novels. Novel addicts can read a thick novel of a few hundred pages in a night or two. “Reading cannot harm you,” exclaim novel readers. The question is: Does a novel really have no effect on the reader? Scientists believe otherwise. According to Dr. Gregory S. Berns, director of Emory University’s Center for Neuropolicy in Atlanta, “Stories shape our lives and in some cases help define a person.” Berns says their findings “suggest that reading a novel can transport you into the body of the protagonist.” Using MRI scans, the investigators noticed heightened connectivity in an area of the brain (of their subjects) which is associated with making representations of sensation for the body. They explain that, for example, when we merely think about running, we can activate neurons in the brain that are associated with the actual physical motion of running.” In the light of the above consider the contents of the vast majority of novels read by young and old alike. If merely thinking of running activates the neurons in the brain associated with running, which will make one want to start running, what happens to a person reading a novel whose entire plot is intertwined with materialism and illicit relationships? If “stories shape our lives” as scientists have found, what happens to the mind (and body) of the person reading the lurid scenes of zina in almost every novel? The minimum disastrous effect that this will most likely result in is that the heart and mind of the reader will regularly become engaged in zina – Allah forbid. When the mind and heart will be repeatedly engaged in zina, what next? Novel-reading is also among the major contributors towards the shameless behaviour that is becoming the norm (merely to highlight this, a non-Muslim librarian expressed his “confusion” to his Muslim friend as to how come so many Muslim girls and young women donned in purdah borrow such “racy” novels. May Allah Ta’ala save us all from such shamelessness). Among the greatest calamities of novel-reading is that such people are very often deprived of reciting the Qur’an Shareef. For every hundred pages of a novel read, not even one page of the Qu’ran Shareef is recited. Inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raajioon! This is borne out by the confession of many novel-readers who repented from this evil “past time”. It is thus not a novel idea to keep a novel as company. (The same applies to the modern-day version of novels — the endless BLOGS blabbing away their fictitious tales). The Hollywood, Bollywood movies, dramas, series and instagram, tiktok reels of today are worse than these novels and is destroying our morals, marriages etc. One should read good authentic Islamic books after consulting with an experienced Aalim. Most of all, daily recite the BOOK OF ALLAH TA’ALA. No book can ever be better company than His book.