omnist.world

Deutsch

Sunni · Compare this tradition with another

Wrong Way Round: The Jetset Journey

no name given · Jamiatul Ulama KZN – Council of Muslim Theologians (Suedafrika) · 2026-09-30 · Durban · Source

Knowledge · main message Humility · carrying Repentance · carrying

Secular education is only a branch of true knowledge and must be subordinated to Islamic Ilm, which leads the human being to Allah and fulfils the true purpose of creation.

We think that knowledge is Ilm. We even think that information can be Ilm. I thought that my expensive, Radd-ul-Abdiyah-based liberal arts education was Ilm. But the essence of our secular education was to deny and refute (Radd) the existence of a higher being and to place the human "self" above everything else

The text argues that many Muslims mistakenly regard secular education as genuine Islamic knowledge (Ilm), when in fact they have only acquired Funn (secular skills). The author reflects on her own liberal arts education and recognises that its values contradicted divine priority. She puts forward the thesis that Ilm – the knowledge that leads to Allah – must come first, so that secular knowledge finds its proper place. As a counterexample to modern secular education, the traditional Madrasa system is cited, which was interdisciplinary and emphasised character formation (Tarbiyyah). Historical scholars such as Ibn Khaldun and al-Khwarizmi are named as role models who were excellent both religiously and secularly. The text concludes with a call to acquire Islamic knowledge and to accept the Shari'ah as the framework for life.

Worldview

what this means
What, according to this text, is the root of the evil?
Turning away from God, indifference, idolatry; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality
Where does the evil reside?
in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual
What helps against it?
insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding; inner transformation, repentance, a change of mind
What is human being according to this text?
willed by God, with a task and a responsibility
Where is history heading?
it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end
What does the text base its claim on?
on the holy scripture of its own tradition; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice
To whom does the text's call for devotion apply?
to one's own fellow believers
Where is the text's criticism directed?
explicitly at both

Related texts from other traditions

by similarity of the analysis, one text per tradition

What the text calls for

Passages cited

Koran 2:120 · Koran 55:48 · Koran 3:191 · Koran 2:32

Measured

Basic stance
-1 from -2 to 2
Insistence
2 of 3
Reach
3 of 5
Concreteness
2 of 3
Boundary
1 of 3, named: Säkular Gebildete / Nicht-Muslime
Time
past 2, present 2, future 1

Analysed with qwen3.8-27b, version v3. The same standards apply to every tradition, see Values.

Show the full text
The least each of us can do is to ensure that we acquire enough Islamic knowledge to live our lives within the Shariah’s parameters. Since not all of us can become Ulema, we must consult with the Ulema ul-Haq — the just scholars — just as we would consult with the best physicians for our physical health or engineers for our homes. Despite the root ilm (to know) appearing in the Qur’an over 750 times in thirteen variations, many of us, including me, have spent our lives not even knowing its real definition. We think knowledge is Ilm. We even think information can be Ilm. I thought my fancy Radd-ul-Abdiyah-based liberals arts education was Ilm. But the very essence of our secular education has been to defy and refute (Radd) the very existence of a higher being, placing the human ‘self’ above all else – persistently and methodically though not always overtly. No matter which ‘ism’ we identify with— socialism, capitalism, feminism, etc — its values rule supreme over all else, including God and His all-embracing guidance. We choose to live, study, earn, govern, and protest according to a set of values crafted by a human mind. We forget that living by the divine Shariah (Islamic guidelines and laws) in pure submission and worship of Allah, Abdiyyah, is the very purpose of our creation. Let me illustrate: Anything akin to humility is unheard of in secular education. Even in the privileged institutions I attended, we couldn’t imagine doing anything in school or at work without ensuring maximum credit, visibility, and compensation for it. Life was about building our resumés and portfolios. Our spiritual, emotional, and other such intangible well-beings were at best fairly irrelevant. We felt invincible, defying our immortality. The ‘just do it,’ carpe diem attitude made us discount consequences— not just in our own lives and the hereafter but across generations and borders. Hiroshima? War on Terror? Genetically mutated food? Killer whales dying in captivity bouncing balls for Sea World’s profit and our bottomless need for entertainment? “Say, ‘Indeed, the guidance of Allah is the [only] guidance.’ If you were to follow their desires after what has come to you of knowledge, you would have against Allah no protector or helper. [Quran, 2:120] Uloom vs Funoon It was only two years ago, at a madrasa orientation, that I learned we were referring to Funn (worldly skills, knowledge), as Ilm all along. Funn literally means ‘branch’ and appears in the Qur’an once – Surah Rahman: 48. From my personal understanding, that’s what worldly studies are: akin to a (tiny) subset of real knowledge. So my life thus-far had been in the name of worldly Funn. Ilm, however, brings us closer to Allah, towards understanding and practicing His beautiful Deen. Ilm helps us prioritize our thoughts and actions in sync with a built-in Akhirah-meter. Call to Action The least each of us can do is to ensure that we acquire enough Islamic knowledge to live our lives within the Shariah’s parameters. Since not all of us can become Ulema, we must consult with the Ulema ul-Haq — the just scholars — just as we would consult with the best physicians for our physical health or engineers for our homes. Right Way Round Life is, of course, not meant to be devoid of Funn (bi-lingual pun unintended). For all Funoon are just that: branches of learning that also testify to the Khaaliq’s infinite beauty in all creation. Funn will automatically fall into place once Ilm is in place, making the paradoxical reality of our lives all the more painful. Acquired with the spirit of serving Allah, after Ilm, permissible Funoon offer rich paths to Allah’s Ridha, or pleasure. “Who remember Allah while standing or sitting or [lying] on their sides and give thought to the creation of the heavens and the earth, [saying],‘Our Lord, You did not create this aimlessly…’” [Qur’an, 3: 191] Blast from the Past: How it’s Done Indeed, many an Aalim (religious scholar) was also highly accomplished in worldly excellence. They range from philosophers and anthropologists credited with the discipline’s foundation: Ibn-e-Batuta, Ibn Khaldun; to innovating mathematicians, al-Khwarizmi, founder of algebra. Many of the Sahaba (ra) were scrupulous, successful businessmen, as was the Tabi`i Imam Abu Hanifa (d. 150 AH), compiler-architect of the first school of jurisprudence, named after him. Theirs was worldly work intended to feed the eternal life, not an indulgent lifestyle. In recent times, Ustad Ahmad Lahori (d. 1060 AH), the chief architect of the Taj Mahal and Jami Masjid Delhi graduated from Madrasa Mulla Abdus Salam, Lahore. Ali Mardan Khan (d. 1067), builder of the fabled Shalamar Gardens in Lahore was also a Madrasa graduate (Faazhil). As were Khairullah Khan Dehlavi (d. 1161) who built the Observatory in Delhi and Ustad Rumi Khan who built cannons for the Mughal King, Babar (d. 937). There are countless more. The pre-colonial Madrasa system incorporated science basics as well as Arabic, Qur’an, Hadith, jurisprudence, astronomy, philosophy, tibb (medicine) and much more. Uncommon today though, graduates went on to apprenticeships or learning crafts, enabling them to lead successful earthly and eternal lives. All in an environment which valued adab (manners, morals and practice) over book learning – and certainly over the exam-centric pattern of today’s institutions. Traditional Islamic Learning: Then and Now And this is how I am taught to this day. The interdisciplinary richness I experienced from the first year in madrasa makes my elite liberal arts college’s specialized interdisciplinary classes seem disjointed, devoid of depth. This system of learning is about an education that makes (wo)men of substance. Students focus on Ilm-un-Nafiun wa Amalan Saalehan (beneficial knowledge and good practice). We must walk our talk and thereby hope to be active givers to society and our own Akhirah. It emphasizes Tarbiyyah (holistic personality and character development) with most professors living lives simply and genuinely personifying traits from the Sunnah, such as deep patience. Our spiritual needs are nurtured, fulfilled. Secular universities, in contrast, deal with consistent suicide rates from students whose lives are oft-devoid of meaningful contentment. Some of my classmates and I have acquired extensive worldly education prior to treading this blessed path too. Having learned them the wrong way round though has come with significant baggage that we’ve had to unlearn. “They said, ‘Exalted are You; we have no knowledge except what You have taught us. Indeed, it is You who is the Knowing, the Wise.’” [Qur’an, 2: 32] By K. Balkhi ____________________________________________________________________________________ The author studied Islam in-depth at Pakistan’s leading Islamic university for women. She has also been a business journalist and writer with over 150 published pieces, including book chapters and strategic reports as part of her former consultancy.