Die wahre Dharma-Praxis besteht nicht im Festhalten an idealisierten Zuständen der Stille, sondern in der Fähigkeit, mit der Vergänglichkeit aller Bedingungen umzugehen und in jeder Situation eine grundlegende Präsenz und das Hinterfragen eigener Ansichten zu wahren.
Der Text reflektiert den Übergang von einer ruhigen Meditationsrückzugssituation in die alltägliche, oft chaotische Welt. Der Sprecher argumentiert, dass die Praxis des Dharma nicht von äußeren Bedingungen wie Stille abhängt, sondern eine innere Ausrichtung auf Präsenz und Wachheit erfordert, die in jeder Situation tragfähig ist. Er warnt davor, sich an verfeinerten Zuständen festzuhalten, da diese vergänglich sind, und ermutigt stattdessen, die veränderliche Natur der Erfahrung anzunehmen. Ein zentraler Punkt ist das Hinterfragen eigener Ansichten und die Bereitschaft, die Unsicherheit des Nicht-Wissens zu akzeptieren, anstatt in der Sicherheit des 'Recht-Habens' zu verharren. Am Beispiel eines weinenden Kindes im Zug wird illustriert, wie Präsenz in unterschiedlichen emotionalen Kontexten gleich bleibt, sich aber in der konkreten Erfahrung unterscheidet. Der Text verbindet persönliche Anekdoten mit buddhistischen Konzepten wie den drei Juwelen und der Vergänglichkeit, um eine alltagsnahe Spiritualität zu fördern.
Analysed with qwen/qwen3.8-27b, version v3.
The same standards apply to every tradition, see Values.
Show the full text
So a few days of contemplating, quietly, at least in an atmosphere of quiet, sometimes of course the inner life doesn't feel very quiet. But a few days, like we were saying this morning of these rare, precious conditions, these conditions that are particularly supportive to a deepening of meditation practice. There's reason that we have a meditation retreat in a situation like this, and not on an urban roundabout. It's supportive for meditation and yet it can sometimes reinforce the idea that, oh, that our practice in the largest sense, Dharma practice, somehow needs some kind of rarefied conditions. And that's not going to be helpful tomorrow when all the rarefied conditions dissolve. A friend of mine took her Tibetan teacher to Hong Kong, Singapore, Singapore maybe. And he had never left the Himalayas prior to that, or maybe he'd been to Delhi once, but anyway. So, from Tibet to the Indian Himalaya. And then they flew into Singapore and kind of intense urban density, and from the airport to the hotel, up in the elevator to the 50th floor, whatever it was. And my friend describes seeing a teacher looking out of one of these floor-to-ceiling windows in the nighttime, with the lights of the cars and the neon signs and the endless blinking lights. And with his back turned to her looking out the windows, he says, oh, very difficult place for meditation. And then he turned back to her with a big smile and said, very good place for Dharma practice. So it might not be quite Singapore that you're going to tomorrow, but maybe wherever you're going, my suggestion would be it's a very good place for Dharma practice. And then we get to certainly encouragement to see what do we take with us? What can we take with us from this kind of environment into any and all other environments? And just as crucially, what can't we take with us? Because it would be a shame if we're trying to take what can't be taken. And if we're forgetting to take what can be taken. And sometimes that's the way, right? We try to take somehow to preserve something which of course is of immense value here. We might find great value in the silence and the simplicity, the inner quietitude that that fosters the refined nervous system that we mentioned yesterday. Forget it. All that is crumbling away. We can't take a set of conditions with us, actually, even from one moment to the next. Even within the relative stability and calm and steadiness and supportiveness of being here. Isn't it also the case that conditions, both outer, environmental and inner, emotional, mental, are flickering, changing? Like you said, nothing lasts. Nothing lasts. And so in moving from one situation to another, well, definitely nothing lasts. So actually that sense of moving graciously through conditions. Actually taking in and acknowledging and living in the light of their changing nature. And then what can we take with us? Well, this orientation, the orientation to presence in the midst of. The orientation, this sort of threefold orientation that we've been exploring this week as the three jewels. That orientation isn't dependent on conditions. Awakeness doesn't become unavailable because we move from one place to another. Or because one mind state changes into another. Or because we start to move a bit little more quickly or because we're talking more. But if our doorway, if our access to a sense of awakeness, to a sense of presence, if the doorway to that has been in these kinds of conditions. Because this is, like I said, supportive conditions for meditation. It's a powerful doorway. Then we might tend to mistake the doorway for the view. And we imagine that, oh, that's that presence belongs in some way to a certain feeling. A feeling of inner quiet, a feeling of a refined nervous system. A feeling of being able to be deep inside the breath. No, today you might be present inside a sense of deep intimacy with the breath. Tomorrow you might be present with being annoyed at somebody talking on the train. So it feels very different. Present inside the breath. Present with annoyance, the crying child on the train. Feels very different. Different situation, same orientation. Present to the way it's unfolding. Present to whatever kind of reactivity has happened. Present to the assumptions I might be making. Present in such a way that allows me to soften those assumptions and meet the essential nature. Breathing body, crying baby. Like they say in India, same same but different. So our practice is, in this sort of situation, can seem to be largely defined by meditation. And the quantity of meditation you'll be doing tomorrow and the next day and the next day probably less. You're welcome to take the schedule home and put it on your fridge. But you know. So what's your practice defined by? Because it's not going to be meditation. If we think of our practice as the way we meet the world. Moment by moment. The way we meet the world. And like we say, unified field. When I say the world, I'm not making any distinction between what we could call the inner world and what we could call the outer world. Just the world of experience. One world is more than enough. The world of experience. The world that we're always, like we've said in the centre of. The world which is always being mirrored back to us. The world in which we're constantly exposed to whatever kinds of assumptions or reactions we're making. The world that in that reflection is inviting us to see through those assumptions. You might see for yourself what those assumptions are. What assumptions do you have? What associations do you have just with that? Just with the world. Just notice what comes to mind. When you hear the world. In fact you might, if something comes to mind and you don't feel shy, just call it out. Assumptions. What associations do you have when you hear the world? Noisy. Noisy. The world. Busy. Under threat. Under threat. Demanding. Scary. Beautiful. Oh, thank you. Beautiful. Anything else? A big map. A big map. So you know, just, you know, which one of those are right? Yeah, just impressions. The world doesn't belong to our assumptions and associations. And our assumptions and associations are changing as well. In one moment the world appears to us in one way. In another moment, another way. It depends on the context. If I'd asked you in another moment without that whole preamble. If I dusted out on the lawn an hour ago when you're just moving on your own, what's the world? Green and sunny or something. So, you know, I practice, I mean, that emphasis to presence, but also that emphasis to actually examining our assumptions and associations and the ways they curate our sense of the world, determine our sense of the world, distort our sense of the world. Narayan and I drove into Totnes at lunchtime today to have lunch with Christopher Titmus, who's co-founder of Guy House and a very old and dear friend and teacher, really my primary teacher for the first 10 years or so of my practice. So I think I said on the first evening, the first time I ever came to a tort at Guy House was assisting Christopher in 1999. And he gave me a copy of his latest 25th book. It's called Questioning Our Views. And including this book includes, among other things, a critique of war, politics, social media, sex trafficking, AI, Gaza, climate change, authoritarianism and more. That's, that's, uh, it's bold. Wading into any of that territory is bold, but he's not, he's not wading into that territory to establish a view, not wading into that territory to drive home a view. No, he's, he's exploring that territory to question our views. And we sort of, you know, you can see for yourself, you know, what, what, what the relationship is to views. Often it's one of, of course, if we hold a view, we tend to think we're right. If we didn't think we're right, we wouldn't hold that view. We would change our mind. Except we often have quite a lot of inertia to changing our mind. Because it turns out we get quite attached to being right. We, as if being right, right, in the certainty of being right, there seems to be, seems to be a kind of security. And to acknowledge that we're not right or that we just, that we don't know. I don't know. Ooh. I don't know. Seems to be a place of insecurity. There's one little poem by R.D. Lang. I wish I, if I knew in advance what I was going to say, I would have brought that part. Maybe you know, there's something I feel I should know. No, I won't Google it. You can look it up. There's R.D. Lang. There's something I should know. Maybe I'll find it for later. It's sort of evokes that territory of what the Buddha calls the thicket. The thicket of views and opinions. If English isn't your first language, a thicket is like a dense, it's brambles, right, thorns. And you know, if you get into a thicket, you get hurt, you get scratched. And the more you move and the more you try to maneuver, the more scratched you get. Sometimes the public discourse around views can seem very much like a thicket. So that sort of encouragement then to question our views, to dare to not know. To put aside the assumption of being right, the need to be right, the seeming security of being right, because it tends to be kind of a brittle kind of a place. It's often a defensive kind of a place. There's a line in the texts where the Buddha talks about people being attached to their place. And it's often seen in the texts as being some kind of encouragement for people to pursue the homeless life. So in the texts, in the life of the Buddha, people would kind of leave home and go off with the Buddha. There's this sort of line where people would have this moment of realisation and they would realise that they were attached to their place. And so saying, the householder so and so did then shave off their head and cast off their fine clothes and take up rags and go forth in homelessness in the dispensation of the Holy One. Confined and dusty is the life of the householder. Open and free is the life of the homeless one and so on. I used to think that to myself sometimes when my kids were younger. Confined and dusty is the life of the householder. But it's always seemed to me that what sana is the parli. Same like asana, right? If in the yoga asana in yoga means posture. So sana or stana in modern Indian language like Hindustan, the place of the Hindus. So people are attached to their sana, their place. And therefore as I say there's this sense of rather being attached to place. There's the homeless wandering yogi life seems to be recommended. But I've always liked to think actually that's a slight misinterpretation of that line. And just in such a way that sana as in asana doesn't so much mean place as it means position. Stana, Hindustan but like stance in English. It's the same etymology, right? It's the same etymological root. People are attached to their stance, attached to their position rather than place geographical place. Get attached to positionality. So that's sort of amidst the complexities of the world, the complexities of circumstance, the complexities of just wherever we find ourselves on the political spectrum, wherever we find ourselves in support of or concern with various cause celebra. The seemingly hot button issues which we can feel sometimes pressured to have some view about to come down on one side or the other of. And then we add our voice to whatever. And of course social media plays a big part in that. That sense that suddenly there's this window to the public discourse. And if you have any kind of public profile, often there's pressure to nail one's colours to the mast in support of this side or that side. One to really question one's position. And two to question what does holding the position accomplish? Often one might feel and may be driven by right, right, a sense of rightness, may be driven by a sense of caring, may be driven by a sense of distress and alarm for what one sees happening in the world. And the kind of intolerable pain of feeling helpless about this or that situation. And in the face of that helplessness, at least if I can say I care about this. At least I can say this is my side. Somehow feel I've done something. I think we have to be careful with the public discourse, especially social media. The main beneficiaries of us expressing some strong view on social media. The main beneficiary of that are the platforms that run social media. Benefit from every click. And the stronger the positions we take, the more others will take a strong position on another side. And the more we'll click and argue and the more money flows into the coffers of those owning the platforms, while we think well I've stated my view. I've aligned myself with the ones that I feel right with. So it's still, it's tricky territory. The world of views. The navigating positionality. And not that I'm advocating no position, no view. Not that I'm advocating and sort of what's the expression. Fence sitting. No, well, there's a bit of... Well, of course, this one and that one. But I think just to see as a practice in itself, like Christopher sang in this book, the questioning of views, the uncomfortable questioning of views, the discomfort of... I don't know. Because sometimes, of course, we do know, sometimes something seems really abundantly clear to us. And if something seems abundantly clear, that itself is actually worth a little questioning. What's the basis for this seeming clear to me? Is it clear? Because I actually feel like there's wisdom and depth and nuance. Or is it abundantly clear because it gives me some sense of security, of righteousness, of being aligned with a certain subset that hold similar views to me, etc. Well, what's the risk? And maybe what's the possibility of not knowing? You see that in the meditation. Even in such a small scale of just sitting here breathing in and out, as soon as I think I know what this is, this breath, this body, this human experience, I shut down a great deal of possibility. I know, I know what that is. Really? Body. Just the idea that I know what this body is. And of course, recourse to image and memory and association and description. Oh, yeah, I know that version. But actually, if I really try to find out just in the moment, actually, body in this mind becomes living, nebulous, uncontainable. And to question our positionality is to give us some access to the nebulous, the nuanced, the multifaceted. There's sense, we look at the world, the Buddhist tradition, the Buddha describes the world in terms of, again, I don't mean the world of geography, I mean the world of experience, the world that the most essentially in and moving through moment by moment. In terms of what in the tradition are called the worldly wins. Worldly wins, what are the worldly wins? Pleasure and pain. Praise and blame. Gain and loss. Success and failure. Those are the wins that blow through all lives. And of course, they only are recognizable because of their opposite. We own only, if I say pleasure, we only know what pleasure is or means because of our reference to its opposite. Any of those that we take, failure, failure and success, they go together. It couldn't be any such thing as success if it didn't stand in opposition to failure. There couldn't be any such thing as gain if it wasn't measurable in counterpoint to loss. It's like, oh yeah, these are the worldly wins that blow through all lives. There's no life that doesn't know both sides of all that. And yet, how easily we treat pleasure and gain and praise and success as what should be happening. I mean, of course we prefer those things, but it's one thing to prefer them. It's another thing to think that's what my life should look like inwardly and outwardly. Pleasure, gain, praise, success. I'm tired already. And then pain, loss, blame, failure. I'm not actually trying to wait those words in different ways, but they just, as I say them, oh, they kind of have that time to them. And yet, into every life, all of those wins have to blow through. Whatever we look at, pleasure and pain, we prefer pleasure. And when possible, we'll choose pleasure. When cold, put on a sweater and enjoy being warm. And yet, of course, it's not always possible. And then what does one do? What's the view that we come up with when we're uncomfortable, when we're experiencing something painful? How easily, in some sense, that this shouldn't happen to me? Why me? Why now? Why like this? How can we construct a whole personality view and then a view about the world, a view about what's right or fair? It's not fair. I mean, that's true. The world isn't fair. Neither is it unfair. It's a good way of avoiding positionality. The world is not fair. And nor is it unfair. Then what is it? It's like this. It's like this. Fair and unfair just isn't a helpful paradigm. Success and failure. How often we might restrain ourselves or shut down the generative or creative impulse to do that which seems the right thing, the good thing, the appropriate thing, the creative thing, for fear of failure. Because failure, I mean, again, just take in the word failure. Failure. Failure. How much does that insult you? Failure. But there's nothing wrong with failure. It's just built in. Life is defined by failure. Everything is going to fail. All of this. I mean, it's already failing. It's failing. It's just to go graciously through the failure of health and vitality and youth. Again, how much does one feel indignant? Well, may well. Sometimes it's like that. I notice myself just sometimes there's a sense of the other gracious going through aging. And then I remember back to what my mind was like in my 20s. Oh, God. I think thank God for our aging. And then another day, we wake up and go into the bathroom and look in the mirror and think, Oh, my God. Indignation. For me at least. It's the good way. Just indignation. Come on. Just when I feel like I know how to move through life, I have the equipment for the moving throughs to fail graciously. There's something really relieving, soothing, liberating. And do you know meditation's excellent practice for failing? How many times a day, how many times an hour do you fail in meditation? You have this setup. Just sit and be present and just rest your attention and breathing. Ding. How long till you fail? And yet even there we can start to manufacture a rhetoric about getting it wrong. And we start to get frustrated with the failure and fail and fail. Trungpa Rinpoche describes Dharma practice as one failure after another. Or elsewhere I think he also says one insult after another. One humiliation. And that sense of failure can be humiliating. If we're attached to our self-image, if we're attached to the way I should be, or the way I should be seen, or attached to the sense of what success will look like and how it's going to prop up my sense of security, then failure of whatever kind can be really humiliating. But if we're interested in failing graciously, if we're not so attached to our self-image, then so-called failure actually can be humbling, rather than humiliating. So going to the stuff of life, moving through the world, moving through the intricacies of the world, moving through the views of the world, the contrast one might have with others' views, the views of the people you work with, the views of the people you live with, the views of friends, the sometimes grating sense of seeing things differently, and whether that's the everyday we encounter people that we have different politics with or from, different views about a whole variety of worldly issues. And we can polarise, again that's such a kind of, such currency in the contemporary world, a polarising views. Or rather than being stuck in right and wrong, I'm right, you're wrong, rather than being attached to our asana, our positionality. Everybody's right. Don't like to hear that, but everybody's right in their own world,